Mobil Loses AAA Status
April 26th, 2016 9:03 pmVia WSJ:
By ERIN AILWORTH and AUSTEN HUFFORD
Updated April 26, 2016 5:48 p.m. ET
Exxon Mobil Corp. was stripped Tuesday of the perfect triple-A credit rating it has held for more than six decades by Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services, a sign that the oil bust is hurting even the strongest players in the energy industry.
The world’s largest publicly traded oil company, Exxon, was just one of three American companies— Microsoft Corp. and Johnson & Johnson are the others—that had the triple-A rating. S&P said it first gave the company the triple-A mark in 1949. A representative for Exxon said it had been triple-A since 1930, counting its predecessor companies.
But the company’s willingness to go into debt to fund its capital spending and keep paying out dividends even as oil prices plunged from highs of over $100 a barrel to as low as $26 has taken a toll on its balance sheet. Its total debt, which stood at $38.7 billion at the end of last year, has more than tripled since 2012, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence.
“Nothing has changed in terms of the company’s financial philosophy or prudent management of its balance sheet,” Exxon spokesman Scott Silvestri said Tuesday.
In downgrading Exxon by one notch to double-A-plus, S&P cited the company’s rising debt level and said dividend payments and share repurchases “substantially exceeded” internally generated cash flow.
U.S. government debt itself is ranked at double-A-plus.
Earlier this year, Exxon sold $12 billion of new bonds in one of the biggest corporate-debt deals of the year. S&P said it expects Exxon to return cash to shareholders instead of reducing its debt.
“Other AAAs have no debt or almost no debt and a lot of cash,” said Ben Tsocanos, an analyst for the ratings agency, in a February interview. “Exxon is the only AAA company in a capital intensive industry. That should be kept in mind.”
The ratings downgrade isn’t expected to affect Exxon’s ability to borrow money. But the triple-A rating status—which Exxon managed to maintain in one form or another through the Great Depression, World War II, Arab oil embargo and several previous price crashes—had long been a point of pride for the Irving, Texas company.
Exxon Chief Executive Rex Tillerson said during an interview with CNBC in March that he’d be disappointed if it lost the triple-A rating. “You know, over 90 years of being AAA, this is not the first time we’ve been through a period of this pretty extreme stress on the financial-model of the company,” he said. “I hope we can maintain the rating ‘cause it’s important to us reputationally.”
Investors rely on ratings from S&P, Moody’s Investors Service and Fitch Ratings when deciding whether to buy bonds.
In February, S&P cut the ratings of 10 U.S. oil and gas exploration and production companies, citing the price decline. It also placed Exxon on watch for a possible downgrade, which was resolved with Tuesday’s release. S&P said Exxon’s outlook is stable.
Also in February, Moody’s Investors Service affirmed its triple-A rating for Exxon but placed the company on a negative outlook, saying it feared a diminished level of capital reinvestment could hurt Exxon’s ability to replace reserves and hurt production in future years. It stood by that rating and outlook in an April 1 credit opinion.
Peter Speer, an analyst with Moody’s, said Exxon’s problem is that it is completing complex, large-scale, expensive projects that don’t work in the current low-price environment.
“There will be higher prices in the future, but not returning anywhere to the prices we saw a few years ago,” Mr. Speer said.
Energy companies have suffered from a prolonged decline in oil and natural gas prices, with many severely cutting planned capital expenditures.
The financial ratings industry has been under criticism in recent years stemming from the high-marks given to mortgage-backed securities, whose failure later caused the financial crisis. In Feb. 2015, S&P agreed to pay $1.5 billion to resolve litigation alleging it knowingly issued rosy grades of risky mortgage bonds before the crisis.